A Field Perspective on Engineering Commissioning Resources
  • Home
    • What's New
  • Blog
    • Blog Support
  • SketchUp Models
    • SketchUp Resources
    • Bureaucratic Affairs Building HHW System Logic Exercise
    • Bureaucratic Affairs Building Scavenger Hunt
    • Chilled Water Plant System Diagram Exercise
    • The HIjend Hotel >
      • Chilled Water Plant Scoping Exercise
      • Ballroom AHU Scoping Exercise
      • Cooling Tower Scoping Exercise
  • Tools
    • Altitude Correction Factor
    • Economizer Evaluation Checklist
    • Eikon for Educators and WindLGC
    • Effective Duct Length Tool
    • Excel Third Axis Tool
    • Excel Time Value Conversion
    • Insulation Savings Tools
    • Logic Diagram Tool
    • Mixed Air Calculations
    • Monitoring Plan Spreadsheet
    • Pipe Friction Chart
    • Plot Digitizer >
      • Plot Digitizer Pump Curve Example
    • Square Law Spreadsheet
    • System Diagram Symbols
    • Thermodynamic Diagrams Spreadsheet
    • Universal Translator Data Analysis Tool
    • y = (m * x) + b Spreadsheet
  • Useful Formulas
    • Affinity Laws
    • Circular Equivalent Duct
    • Effective Duct Length
    • FT Guide Appendix C
    • HVAC Equations and Concepts
    • Hydraulic Diameter
    • Pump Power and Energy
    • "Square Law"
  • What's That Thing?
    • Cooling Towers
    • Pumps
    • Valves
  • Resources
    • Bill Coad's Writings
    • Data Logging Resources
    • EBCx Skills Guidebook
    • Energy Design Resources
    • Fisher Controls Valve Cavitation Bulletin
    • Functional Testing Guide
    • Honeywell Gray Manual
    • MCC Powers Bulletins
    • NBCIP Reports
    • PEC Tool Lending Library
    • PID Resources
    • Pneumatic Control Resources
    • Resource List
    • Scoping Resources
    • TAB Resources
    • Vintage Carrier Design Manual
    • VRF Systems
    • Williams' Wisdom
  • Videos
    • Bureaucratic Affairs HHW Logic Answers
    • Cooling Tower Flow Variation
    • Economizer Stratification
    • Functional Testing
    • Induction Principles
    • Monitoring Plans
    • Ripple Effects
    • Testing a Pump
    • The Garden of Low Entropy
    • Variable Flow Systems
  • Training
    • Materials from Classes and Presentations >
      • ACEEE
      • ASHRAE
      • ASHRAE - Engineers Notebook
      • BCxA and NCBC
      • BEST Institute
      • Case Studies
      • ERDC 2020 RCx Academy
      • ELPNW
      • ICEBO
      • Marriott AEP
      • Magazine Articles
      • NAVFAC
      • Pacific Energy Center Design, Performance and Commissioning Issues Classes >
        • PEC Class Materials Archive
      • Pacific Energy Center EBCx Project Review
      • Pacific Energy Center EBCx Workshop Series >
        • EBCx Workshop Series 12
        • EBCx Workshop Series 13
        • EBCx Workshop Series 14
        • EBCx Workshop Series 15 >
          • Student One On One Discussions
        • EBCx Workshop Series 16
        • EBCx Workshop Series 17
      • Portland General Electric
      • U of W >
        • U of W Archive
    • On Demand Training >
      • Fans, Ducts and AHUs
      • Induction Motor Principles
      • Introduction to Functional Testing
      • Scope of Work Documents
    • Training Opportunities
  • Contact
    • Copyright and Permissions
  • Home
    • What's New
  • Blog
    • Blog Support
  • SketchUp Models
    • SketchUp Resources
    • Bureaucratic Affairs Building HHW System Logic Exercise
    • Bureaucratic Affairs Building Scavenger Hunt
    • Chilled Water Plant System Diagram Exercise
    • The HIjend Hotel >
      • Chilled Water Plant Scoping Exercise
      • Ballroom AHU Scoping Exercise
      • Cooling Tower Scoping Exercise
  • Tools
    • Altitude Correction Factor
    • Economizer Evaluation Checklist
    • Eikon for Educators and WindLGC
    • Effective Duct Length Tool
    • Excel Third Axis Tool
    • Excel Time Value Conversion
    • Insulation Savings Tools
    • Logic Diagram Tool
    • Mixed Air Calculations
    • Monitoring Plan Spreadsheet
    • Pipe Friction Chart
    • Plot Digitizer >
      • Plot Digitizer Pump Curve Example
    • Square Law Spreadsheet
    • System Diagram Symbols
    • Thermodynamic Diagrams Spreadsheet
    • Universal Translator Data Analysis Tool
    • y = (m * x) + b Spreadsheet
  • Useful Formulas
    • Affinity Laws
    • Circular Equivalent Duct
    • Effective Duct Length
    • FT Guide Appendix C
    • HVAC Equations and Concepts
    • Hydraulic Diameter
    • Pump Power and Energy
    • "Square Law"
  • What's That Thing?
    • Cooling Towers
    • Pumps
    • Valves
  • Resources
    • Bill Coad's Writings
    • Data Logging Resources
    • EBCx Skills Guidebook
    • Energy Design Resources
    • Fisher Controls Valve Cavitation Bulletin
    • Functional Testing Guide
    • Honeywell Gray Manual
    • MCC Powers Bulletins
    • NBCIP Reports
    • PEC Tool Lending Library
    • PID Resources
    • Pneumatic Control Resources
    • Resource List
    • Scoping Resources
    • TAB Resources
    • Vintage Carrier Design Manual
    • VRF Systems
    • Williams' Wisdom
  • Videos
    • Bureaucratic Affairs HHW Logic Answers
    • Cooling Tower Flow Variation
    • Economizer Stratification
    • Functional Testing
    • Induction Principles
    • Monitoring Plans
    • Ripple Effects
    • Testing a Pump
    • The Garden of Low Entropy
    • Variable Flow Systems
  • Training
    • Materials from Classes and Presentations >
      • ACEEE
      • ASHRAE
      • ASHRAE - Engineers Notebook
      • BCxA and NCBC
      • BEST Institute
      • Case Studies
      • ERDC 2020 RCx Academy
      • ELPNW
      • ICEBO
      • Marriott AEP
      • Magazine Articles
      • NAVFAC
      • Pacific Energy Center Design, Performance and Commissioning Issues Classes >
        • PEC Class Materials Archive
      • Pacific Energy Center EBCx Project Review
      • Pacific Energy Center EBCx Workshop Series >
        • EBCx Workshop Series 12
        • EBCx Workshop Series 13
        • EBCx Workshop Series 14
        • EBCx Workshop Series 15 >
          • Student One On One Discussions
        • EBCx Workshop Series 16
        • EBCx Workshop Series 17
      • Portland General Electric
      • U of W >
        • U of W Archive
    • On Demand Training >
      • Fans, Ducts and AHUs
      • Induction Motor Principles
      • Introduction to Functional Testing
      • Scope of Work Documents
    • Training Opportunities
  • Contact
    • Copyright and Permissions

Circular Equivalent of a Duct and Equivalent Diameter

 Most of the duct friction charts that are out there are based on round ducts.   That means that if you are working with a rectangular duct or a flat oval duct, you will need to come up with the equivalent circular duct size if you are using some other cross sectional shape, like rectangular duct or flat oval duct. The terms Circular Equivalent of a Duct and Equivalent Diameter sound like the same thing, but technically, there are two different concepts with different formulas for calculating them.

The circular equivalent of a duct formulas are published by ASHRAE and are used to compare different shaped ducts in terms of their air handling capacity and to allow you to use a duct friction chart that is based on round duct for other duct shapes.   The equivalent diameter formula is published by AMCA and is used to determine effective duct length.
Why Different Shapes?
Equivalent Diameter Formula
Circular Equivalent Formulas
Resources
 


​
​Why Different Duct Shape?

  ou may be wondering why ducts come in different shapes in the first place.  If there is no constraint on space, then, for a given volume of air at a given friction rate, round duct will probably be the best choice for a number of reasons including:
  • Less weight, which has both a structural and a cost implication.
  • Less perimeter, which means insulating costs will be lower and the surface are for heat transfer to occur through is smaller.
  • Less low frequency break-out noise;  i.e. rectangular ducts are more likely to rumble.
Square ducts exhibit similar characteristics.   But as the aspect ratio of a square duct starts to increase above 1 (a wider, thinner duct), then the duct cross-sectional area required to deliver a give flow rate at a give friction rate will increase because the square inches of area contained per inch of perimeter starts to drop from what it would be for a square duct or rectangular duct.   

An interesting aspect of the fact that a higher aspect ratio duct requires a larger cross-section to deliver a given flow rate at a given friction rate is that the velocity in the high aspect ratio ducts will be lower than they would be for a square or round duct carrying the same flow at the same friction rate.  Since the pressure drop through a duct fitting is a function of the velocity pressure and the velocity pressure is a function of the square of the velocity, the preceding implies that a poor fitting design will be a bigger problem in a round duct or square duct compared to the same fitting design applied in a higher aspect ratio duct sized for the same air flow and friction rate.

The table below illustrates some of the points made above.
Picture
As duct sizes increase, the number of square inches encompassed by each inch of perimeter also increases.  That implies that for a given friction rate, large ducts will have much higher velocities (and thus, operate at much higher velocity pressures) than small ducts.   This in turn implies that a poor fitting design in a large duct can be a much more significant problem than an identical poor fitting design in a small duct because the loss through a fitting is a function of the velocity pressure, which in turn, is a function of the square of the velocity.

The table below illustrates this phenomenon.
Picture
 


​​
​Circular Equivalent of a Duct

Rectangular Ducts

ASHRAE defines this as the diameter of a rectangular duct that has equal resistance to flow for an equal flow rate and length.   It is not the same thing as the AMCA term Equivalent Duct, which will be discussed in the next section.   
Picture

Flat-Oval Ducts

ASHRAE also publishes a formula for calculating the circular equivalent of a flat-oval duct.
Picture
 


​
​Equivalent Diameter

AMCA Standard 201 defines the term equivalent duct diameter as the diameter of a circle having the same cross sectional area as another geometric shape.  In other words, the AMCA equivalency term is focused on a dimensional equivalency where-as the ASHRAE equivalency term is focused on air handling equivalency.  Thus, the terms represent two different concepts and the results of the formulas can not be use interchangeably.
Picture
 



Resources

The downloads below will give you to the .wmf files  that are discussed above so you can use them to document your math in a spreadsheet, report, or presentation.   You may also find the following related information on the website to be helpful:
  • Hydraulic diameter is a concept that is similar but not identical to the circular equivalent of a duct size and is discussed on the Hydraulic Diameter page of the website.
  • The Effective Duct Length spreadsheet tool has the equations for 100% effective duct length, circular equivalent duct size, equivalent diameter, and hydraulic diameter built into it to allow you to enter a flow rate and your duct dimensions and calculate the various metrics.

Home

Blog

Resources

Contact

Picture
A Field Perspective on Engineering - © 2017 Facility Dynamics Engineering, All Rights Reserved
(Contact Me to Check on Lefts or Any Other Questions You May Have about Permissions)